Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Is dark matter a candidate to fill void left by luminiferous ether as a medium for light travel?

share|improve this question
6  
no. the michelson morley experiment shows that there exists nothing with the attributes of ether and special relativity has made everything consistent. what void? –  anna v Sep 1 at 13:10
    
What is to prevent dark matter from being hypothesized as a medium of propagation? –  user56930 Sep 1 at 13:16
7  
Are you saying that you don't believe light can propagate in a vacuum? –  Danu Sep 1 at 13:20
2  
@user56930 the fact that light propagates equally well in areas with very little DM as it does in areas with high concentrations of DM. That tends to indicate it has no role as a medium of propagation. Otherwise density changes would produce optical effects –  Jim Sep 1 at 19:56
    
Thanks. Does sound travel at varying speeds through a bell jar as air is pumped out of it? –  user56930 Sep 1 at 19:59

1 Answer 1

No.

There is no void left by the lack of an aether. The very notion of aether should serve as a warning as to how catastrophically analogical reasoning can fail. "Water waves are in water, sound waves are in air, therefore there must be something in which light propagates." This is flawed logic, and decades of physics were arguably hindered by adhering to it.

In fact, any material medium for light would contradict the beautiful result of Michelson and Morley, showing that the speed of light does not depend on velocity with respect to some material's frame. This invariance is in fact now at the very heart of modern physics, and is the basis for relativity, which has been verified in innumerable experiments.

Dark matter is, according to the leading theories, some form of matter that is basically normal except that it essentially doesn't interact via the electromagnetic force. As such, it is actually a poor candidate for explaining anything to do with light, even if there were something that needed explaining.

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks for your time. I'm sure the void I speak of is the void in my own. understanding. Suffice to ask only: is there anything to prevent the hypothesis that dark matter might propagate anything as a medium. Perhaps my question is not a fair question. –  user56930 Sep 1 at 13:25
3  
Things can only propagate stuff they interact with. Dark matter's sole reason for existing is that we see evidence of stuff that interacts via gravity and essentially nothing else. So it can have gravitational effects, but e.g. gravitational waves, like light, don't need a medium to propagate in. –  Chris White Sep 1 at 13:29
    
"Water waves are in water, sound waves are in air, therefore there must be something in which light propagates." ... There is something in which light propagates: the electromagnetic field. It just happens to be a field that is Lorentz invariant. –  user1247 Sep 1 at 13:38
1  
Dark matter may propagate sound, i.e. pressure waves of some type. In general it has been hypothesized to fit the gravitational orbits of galactic clusters, so dark matter is not something permeating all space uniformly. –  anna v Sep 1 at 13:40
1  
@user1247 the electromagnetic field is actually a varying electric and magnetic field with energy and momentum, not permeating all space either. –  anna v Sep 1 at 13:42

protected by Qmechanic Sep 20 at 9:55

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality answers, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site.

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.