Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Does a man on the moon (or any other similar body) experience daytime like we do? By daytime I mean looking upward and seeing a bright "sky," not dark space.

If not, then what is the reason behind it?

share|improve this question
2  
Define "daytime". Then think a little about it. –  Carl Witthoft Jun 22 at 11:49
3  
I mean the time of day...like even when light gets on the moon why does the space appears dark from the moon? –  Abdullah Jun 22 at 11:53
3  
@Abdullah because the moon has no atmosphere which is needed to get a blue sky. –  Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen Jun 22 at 19:12
2  
It's astounding how overly-complex these answers are. Huge fail by the community of physics educators. Abdullah, when you see (as you put it perfectly) a bright sky, not dark space: what you are looking at IS THE AIR. It's that simple. Any planet with no atmosphere (eg, our Moon) - you just see darkness. Any planet with an atmosphere (eg, Earth, Tatooine) you see what you describe. Fantastic question! –  Joe Blow Jun 24 at 8:33

3 Answers 3

up vote 31 down vote accepted

like even when light gets on the moon why does the space appears dark from the moon?

For the same reason it appears dark from the Earth (when flying at an altitude of 80,000 feet or so):

enter image description here

Image credit: View from the SR-71 Blackbird.

The fact is, we can't 'see space' from the Earth's surface during the day because the atmosphere is 'in the way'- the atmosphere scatters light from the Sun and other sources of light and we see that rather than the darkness of space.

If we fly high enough so that most of the atmosphere is below us, we can 'see space' through the little bit of atmosphere above us.

Since the Moon has no atmosphere, the light from the Sun is not scattered and the sky appears dark from the surface of the Moon.

share|improve this answer
2  
+1, for its simplicity. May I suggest an edit: Scatters light from the sun and other sources of light (see e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light_pollution) –  phresnel Jun 23 at 8:32
    
To give credit where credit is due for the great photo, according to Google Image it's shot from an SR-71 Blackbird cockpit, and appears on Wikipedia (among other places). Actually, you don't need to fly at 80,000 feet to start to see a very dark sky -- even from an airliner below 40,000 it's dark, but not enough to see stars. –  Phil Perry Jun 23 at 16:49
    
Thanks!helpful indeed.....but what about other planets some of which have atmosphere(e.g. Venus which has an atmosphere consisting mostly of Carbon Dioxide).Now, I came to know that the light coming from the sun interacts with the tiny molecules and the blue region(with much low wavelength) only gets scattered and enters our eyes and thus the sky appears blue.Now that some molecules are present in venus..even then the sky would appear dark? Reference wind.caspercollege.edu/~marquard/astronomy/… –  Abdullah Jun 24 at 7:21
1  
HI Abdullah. Great follow-up question. In a word: it doesn't matter what the atmosphere is. If it has an atmosphere, you will see a bright "sky," not dark space as you astutely put it. If it has a very thin/no atmosphere, you see just the dark of space. The situation is fully and completely explained here, for every known planet-like body en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraterrestrial_skies –  Joe Blow Jun 24 at 8:37
    
Thanks @JoeBlow!! I get it now! –  Abdullah Jun 25 at 5:43

As you have probably noticed, the moon is tidally locked with the earth so that we always see the same side. You can look up in the sky and watch sunlight move across the moon's face. From the surface of the moon this change in illumination would look just like the day/night cycle on Earth ... except that it's roughly a month long.

Until the advent of radar astronomy it was believed that the planet Mercury was tidally locked to the sun the way that the moon is tidally locked to the earth; this would have meant Mercury would have a "day side" and a "night side" and no sunrises or sunsets; the technical term for this is a "one-to-one tidal resonance." However Mercury has a slightly different tidal resonance with each solar day lasting two orbits. Mercury's orbit is eccentric enough that, seen from the surface of the planet, the sun would occasionally show retrograde motion; there are longitudes on Mercury where the retrograde motion would give you a "false sunrise," shortly followed by a sunset in the east, before the sun rose into the sky for the next 90-ish earth days.

Apart from Uranus, whose axis is tilted so strongly that nearly the entire planet experiences polar days, and Venus, whose (very slow) rotation is retrograde so that the sun rises in the west and sets in the east, the other planets in the solar system have day-night cycles essentially like earth's. Nothing is known about day-night cycles on extrasolar planets.

As to your followup comment about a bright sky without stars, that is a property of the atmosphere. If you've been to a stage play you may have seen the trick where there is a "background" painted on a fairly fine wire mesh. When an actor is in the spotlight in downstage of the mesh it looks opaque. Then the downstage lights go off and upstage lights go on, and suddenly you can can see through the mesh where there is a different actor and a different set. (I assume this technique has a name, but I don't know it.) The atmosphere functions essentially like the screen. During the daytime the atmosphere is bright, and you can only see the very brightest things behind it: the sun, the moon, not much else. During the night the atmosphere is dark, and the dim objects behind it come into view. If you compare a moonlit and moonless night, or a city sky to a country sky, you'll see that that other light sources have the same effect on the atmosphere; from Saturn, for instance, the ring system would stand tall in both the day and night skies.

share|improve this answer
1  
Highly informative. +1 –  New_new_newbie Jun 22 at 14:52
    
Not being able to see the stars during the day isn't, in practical terms, a property of the atmosphere. Even on the moon, during daylight, the reflected light from the ground is bright enough that your eyes won't see the stars. (I suppose you might be able to see stars from the moon in daylight if you "played telescopes" by looking through a cardboard tube, in a direction away from the sun; of course, that doesn't work on earth and that is because of the atmosphere.) –  David Richerby Jun 23 at 12:23
    
"each solar day lasting two orbits." Incorrect. Mercury rotates 3 times over two orbits (revolutions), so each "24 hour" day is 2/3 of a year. –  Phil Perry Jun 23 at 14:04
1  
@rob, good point about sidereal vs tropical/solar days. It's seldom clear which they're talking about. A little more reading seems to say that the year is 87.97 Earth solar days and a sidereal day (one rotation) is 58.65 Earth solar days. This means 3 complete rotations (tidally locked) per 2 revolutions, but one Mercurian solar day lasts two revolutions. So, I'll concede your point in your answer. Nice diagram on enchantedlearning.com/subjects/astronomy/planets/mercury/…. What a strange place! –  Phil Perry Jun 24 at 2:41
1  
@rob Neil Armstrong states in this interview that he couldn't see anything in the sky apart from the sun and earth. However, it seems that Gene Cernan on Apollo 17 was able to see stars in some circumstances. I've not had time to track down proper sources for that. –  David Richerby Jun 24 at 7:51

I just wanted this to be a comment, but it got too long. Sorry if it's too obscure.

This addresses why the sky seems like it has a solid blueish colour, and why moon does not have a bright day.

Since as of no answer mentions it I just wanted to say, that the effect "responsible" for the blue sky is called Rayleigh scattering. "Technically" it's a mid-energy photon-matter interaction, that is described as elastic scattering. This means it can be perceived like the photons bumps of the molecules, but they do not change their properties except for the direction.

It is occurring in the atmosphere, thus the celestial bodies that do not posses it will not have a "solid coloured" sky. As a matter of fact, it works both ways, the light from earth is also scattered, this is why skies over cities "look less starry" the atmosphere is brighter from all the night lights. It's called light pollution.

The wikipedia article covers the description of the effect pretty nicely. Basically it says that under certain conditions photons scatter on the particles or molecules. The conditions are usually met for opaque athmospheres. One of the properties is, the "strength" of scattering depends (quite heavily) on the wavelength. The blue portion is being scattered relatively more than the red (it depends on many variables). This is why it seems like the sky during the day has a rather solid blue colour. This is also why the sun itself appears yellowish. If you take out blue wavelengths from the white the rest of visible spectrum appears yellowish.

The "solidness" comes from the amount of molecules of air there is and their random movement, even though light comes from sun from a rather specified direction. But random movement and orientation molecules in a gas, makes the direction of scattered photons after a bump also random, this is why the blue light comes from every direction.

The same effect also explains why the sun gets red on sunset. The light needs to travel a longer way through the atmosphere, thus more of blue and also more significant portions of green and yellow of wavelengths are "taken" from its original light and colour. This is why it is dimmer, and look red/orange.

I hope I kept it simple but still physical, so one get a deeper meaning of "why" sky looks like it does.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.