Take the 2-minute tour ×
Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Today I learnt about Ohm's Law(I had some basic knowledge earlier).When I came home I searched in the internet and found that at Ohm's Law, resistance should not change because then the circuit will not obey Ohm's Law.I googled about this "problem" but I found nothing. My physic professor says that resistance can change at Ohm's Law. I don't know which one to trust. Can anyone help me ?

share|improve this question
    
First you searched on the internet & got something... Then, you Googled & found nothing.. Aren't both contradictory? –  Sachin Shekhar Feb 26 at 2:11
    
I found a book in the internet where this was written, but when I searched in google about that I found nothing(I mean I only found the same book) –  Panarit Mar 3 at 16:17
    
Give the link to the book.. –  Sachin Shekhar Mar 3 at 16:31

3 Answers 3

up vote 1 down vote accepted

Well, the thing with Ohm's law is that the ordinary expression $I=\frac{V}{R}$ (sorry, I'm on mobile and writing "nice math" here is a pain), works only for what is usually referred to as "static resistance", that is $R=\frac{V}{I}$. However, this implies a material whose resistance does not vary. There are some materials whose resistance varies inversely to its cross-sectional area and proportionally its length ($R=k\frac{l}{A}$, where $k$ is the coefficient of resistivity of a material, a constant really). For this materials you need a "dynamic resistance" which is given by $\frac{dV}{dI}$, simply the rate of change of $V$ with respect to $I$ (or the slope of said line).

share|improve this answer
    
Thanks for the editing! Also, I made a small mistake, regarding k which I already fixed (I believe). –  Demian Licht Feb 25 at 21:07
    
You haven't explored the true reason why Ohm's Law fails for certain materials. It isn't because "resistance varies inversely to its cross-sectional area and proportionally its length" - this is the case for most wires, for example, but Ohm's Law continues to generally apply here. Rather, certain electronic devices are fundamentally non-linear, such as the diode, semiconductor, light bulb, etc. –  Draksis Feb 25 at 22:31

Ohm's law isn't actually a law, in the sense that everything has to obey it. It's more like "This simple pattern that Ohm noticed". Devices exist that don't even come close to obeying Ohm's law, and they're used all the time. Ohm's law basically states that how well something resists current doesn't depend on how big that current is: the device isn't any better at holding back high current than low current. While this is true for many materials, people have specifically designed and made great use of materials that have other properties. Things that, for example, resist current going one way but not another. Or ones that resist low enough levels of current, but can't hold high ones back at all. These are called diodes.

Ohm's law is a nice thing to have, but it's not a rule like conservation of energy or charge.

share|improve this answer

Ohm's law is not quite precise in our daily life.

It varies according to external factors such as temperature, pressure, material of wire used. There are also errors while calculating it. You have maintain standard temperature and pressure (i.e. 273 K and 1 atm). You should also be aware that the conductor whose resistance you are calculating must not get heated which may increase in the collisions of electrons inside the conductor which in return increases the resistance.

There are certain limitations of Ohm's Law

(a) V ceases to be proportional to I (Fig. 3.5).

enter image description here

(b) The relation between V and I depends on the sign of V. In other words, if I is the current for a certain V, then reversing the direction of V keeping its magnitude fixed, does not produce a current of the same magnitude as I in the opposite direction (Fig. 3.6). This happens, for example, in a diode.

enter image description here

(c) The relation between V and I is not unique, i.e., there is more than one value of V for the same current I (Fig. 3.7). A material exhibiting such behaviour is GaAs.

enter image description here

Materials and devices not obeying Ohm’s law are actually widely used in electronic circuits.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.